Is affirmative action hurting minorities in Law School?

freshman · 10-15-2007

There is a bunch of press on the news right now on Affirmative Action causing unqualified people to be admitted only to be rejected later on..

Do you agree?

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,301722,00.html

Quote:

"Currently only about one in three African-Americans who goes to an American law school passes the bar on the first attempt and a majority never become lawyers at all," says UCLA law professor Richard Sander.

In an article published in the Stanford Law Review, Sander and his research team concluded several thousand would-be black lawyers either dropped out of law school or failed to pass the bar because of affirmative action.

Known as the ‘mismatch’ effect, Sander claims students who are unprepared and whose academic credentials are below the median are admitted to law schools they are unqualified to attend. If those same students instead were to go to less elite or competitive schools, more would graduate, pass the bar and become lawyers.

"This is a serious issue and we need to see more research in the area of mismatch," argues Gail Heriot, a professor of law at the University of San Diego and a member of the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. "What we need now is more cooperation from the California Bar" Association.

seth · 10-15-2007

"If those same students instead were to go to less elite or competitive schools, more would graduate, pass the bar and become lawyers."

Nonsense. It's not the competition that keeps minorities from passing the bar - it's basic skills. Competition matters in law school because everything's graded on the curve. The bar exam isn't. Period. Either you understand the legal issues and can write about them or you can't.

Too many law schools, wanting a "diverse" population, admit minority students who don't have the necessary skills in writing and analysis. Professional school is not the place to learn how to write; if you didn't learn that in college, you're going to be in trouble all through law school. You may graduate - someone has to be at the bottom of the class, after all - but you won't be able to pass the bar, which is graded blind. The exam readers don't care about your race or your background and they don't know your name.

Admitting students with low LSAT scores and low college GPAs does them no favors, especially when they take out huge loans that will take them years to pay back while working as something other than lawyers.

View Poll Results: Is Affirmative Action hurting minorities?
Yes	5	55.56%
No	4	44.44%
No comment	0	0%
Voters: 9. You may not vote on this poll

10-15-2007	#2
seth New Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 2	Re: Is affirmative action hurting minorities in Law School? "If those same students instead were to go to less elite or competitive schools, more would graduate, pass the bar and become lawyers." Nonsense. It's not the competition that keeps minorities from passing the bar - it's basic skills. Competition matters in law school because everything's graded on the curve. The bar exam isn't. Period. Either you understand the legal issues and can write about them or you can't. Too many law schools, wanting a "diverse" population, admit minority students who don't have the necessary skills in writing and analysis. Professional school is not the place to learn how to write; if you didn't learn that in college, you're going to be in trouble all through law school. You may graduate - someone has to be at the bottom of the class, after all - but you won't be able to pass the bar, which is graded blind. The exam readers don't care about your race or your background and they don't know your name. Admitting students with low LSAT scores and low college GPAs does them no favors, especially when they take out huge loans that will take them years to pay back while working as something other than lawyers.

Tools	Search
Show Printable Version Email this Question	Search: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Question	Question Asker	Section	Answers	Last Post
Why you should not go to Law School	freshman	Law	2	4 Weeks Ago 06:57 PM
Can I take bar exam after getting law degree online?	imgood	Law	3	11-05-2007 04:31 PM
Law School Do***entary Film Resource	tols	Law	1	10-14-2007 02:33 AM
Preparing for the 2008 Philippines Bar Exam	heelate	Law	1	10-14-2007 02:06 AM
Law School Tutoring Available!	coachbre	Law	0	10-14-2007 12:39 AM

Is affirmative action hurting minorities in Law School?

Is affirmative action hurting minorities in Law School?

View Poll Results: Is Affirmative Action hurting minorities?

Similar Threads